Your Best Finish Starts With TTX!
Published

Benefits of High-Resolution Detector in an X-Ray Fluorescence Analyzer

If you are wondering when to switch your XRF to a newer model with a high-resolution detector, Hitachi High-Tech Analytical Science’s Matt Kreiner has some tips.

Matt Kreiner, Product Manager , Hitachi High-Tech Analytical Science

Share

Q: How do I know if I should switch my XRF to a newer model with a high-resolution detector?

A: Typical XRF coating analyzers are 10 years old, so it’s possible that when you last purchased an instrument there were very limited, if any, detector options. Therefore, you chose the instrument with the best performance and features that fit into your budget and sample-size requirements.

The most common detector around 10 years ago was a gas-filled proportional counter (PC) detector. In the last decade, XRF detector technology has advanced to include innovations such as solid-state or semiconductor detectors — PIN diodes and silicon drift detectors (SDD). These detectors offer additional benefits for several of today’s more advanced applications. Even if you purchased an instrument a few years ago, it’s possible your requirements have already changed or may change in the future, so it’s worth understanding when it’s time to switch to a high-resolution, solid-state detector. Here are a few key considerations:

When many elements or neighboring elements are in the sample, including alloyed plating. Examples — Cr/Ni/Cu/Zn, ZnNi/Fe. One of the key features of an SDD is improved resolution. Much like high-definition television improves your ability to see features of a moving picture, the higher the resolution of an XRF detector, the greater its ability to see more details in an XRF spectrum. With XRF, the detector is responsible for differentiating small energy differences to determine what elements are present. A PC detector has comparatively poor resolution and cannot clearly see the series of characteristic signals from neighboring elements. An example of this is when zinc is plated with copper and nickel. These elements cannot be fully resolved by a PC detector, so a combination spectral interpretation software and special hardware may be employed, sometimes resulting in sequential analysis. With an SDD, these elements are seen clearly and simultaneously. Measurements can be taken in less time and with improved accuracy.

When coatings are thin (for example, less than 10 microinch). Example — Au/Ni/Cu. Due to the design of solid-state detectors, the background noise is markedly lower than on a PC detector, making it easier to resolve the signal from the elements to be measured from unwanted signal. While this doesn’t have a significant impact when measuring thick coatings, it can be critical when measuring very thin coatings (less than 10 microinch). At that range, variations in background can be the difference between a good analysis and a nondetect reading. Solid-state detectors have very stable and low background noise, resulting in good sensitivity to detect and analyze thin coatings.

When you need to measure phosphorus content in electroless nickel plating and conversion coatings. Example — NiP/Al, ZnP/Fe. Elements with atomic numbers less than 17 (chlorine) present some challenges for XRF coatings instruments. These elements do not travel well through the air and, by the time they travel from the sample surface to the detector, they have lost much of their signal, making them harder to analyze than their more energetic counterparts. The combined sensitivity, resolution and background of a solid-state detector makes it possible to directly detect and quantify phosphorus, even for thin layers of low-phosphorus electroless nickel.

Detector choice can be a complicated subject, and there are many applications where a PC detector performs very well and may be preferable to a PIN diode or SDD. It’s important to choose the right XRF equipment supplier who will consult with you and determine the best technology for your business needs.

Matt Kreiner is the Product Manager for Hitachi High-Tech Analytical Science’s coatings analysis products. Visit hha.hitachi-hightech.com.

Your Best Finish Starts With Us!
Precision gear pumps
ENGINEERED PAINT BOOTHS & FINISHING SOLUTIONS
Metal Pretreatment Technology
OptiCenter All-in-One OC11
Filtration Systems
PF Podcast
plating and surface finishing additives
Gardner Intelligence
Heatmax Heaters ad with immersion heaters
The Finishing Industry’s Education and Networking Resource
Heatmax Heaters ad with immersion heaters

Related Content

Powder Coating

Coatings Plant Evolves with Market Trends

Expanding its focus from exclusively serving the RV industry, one of this company’s stand-alone coatings plant has successfully extended its services to additional markets.

Read More
Liquid Coating

Surface Prep Solution for Rusted Rebar in Concrete

Julie Holmquist of Cortec Corporation discusses passivating corrosion on rebar and other reinforcing metals.

Read More
automotive

Henry Ford Is Still Right When It Comes to Color

Who would have imagined that more than 100 years after his famous statement about any color as long as it’s black would still have relevance of a sort?

Read More
automotive

Robots, AI and Superb BMW Surfaces

There isn’t an automotive paint shop in the world that doesn’t have post-paint inspection and defect processing. But BMW is doing this with levels of technology at a plant in Germany that exceed all other paint shops in the world.

Read More

Read Next

Parts Cleaning

A ‘Clean’ Agenda Offers Unique Presentations in Chicago

The 2024 Parts Cleaning Conference, co-located with the International Manufacturing Technology Show, includes presentations by several speakers who are new to the conference and topics that have not been covered in past editions of this event.   

Read More
regulation

Episode 45: An Interview with Chandler Mancuso, MacDermid Envio Solutions

Chandler Mancuso, technical director with MacDermid Envio discusses updating your wastewater treatment system and implementing materials recycling solutions to increase efficiencies, control costs and reduce environmental impact.

Read More
Sponsored

Delivering Increased Benefits to Greenhouse Films

Baystar's Borstar technology is helping customers deliver better, more reliable production methods to greenhouse agriculture.

Read More
Industrial Finishing Equipment