Vacuum Degreasers and Aqueous Solutions
Published

Boosting the Power of Immersion Degreasing

How do you make your parts cleaning operation more efficient? Add agitation, says Bex’s Steve Phillips.

Steve Phillips, Bex Inc.

Share

Q. How can we boost the immersion degreasing operation for cleaning parts in our shop?

A. Cleanliness specifications continue to rise for manufacturers of high-precision components in every sector. Aqueous cleaning in immersion (soak) tanks is the standard. Agitation makes the process more efficient and reduces cycle times. 

In an aqueous degreasing tank, a static boundary layer with soil-saturated surfactants forms next to the part surface to be cleaned. This layer erects a barrier between the part surface and most of the cleaning agent, reducing degreasing potential. Creating agitation in the tank disrupts this layer and allows fresh solution to contact the part’s surface, accelerating cleaning. There are several ways to create agitation:

Air spargers are a common agitation method, but one with serious downsides. These include damage to the cleaning solution, uneven results and excessive foaming. But introducing air into the tank has predictable consequences: 

  1. Air brings in carbon dioxide (CO2), which forms carbonic acid that reacts with the alkaline components of the aqueous solution, diminishing its effectiveness. 
  2. Acid formation reduces the solution’s service life by lowering its pH, compromising its corrosion inhibitors. 
  3. Input air, contaminated by the compressor (or atmosphere), often causes oil to be introduced into the tank.
  4. Bubbles are not a serious agitation method for thorough and predictable tank mixing.
  5. Air or vapor bubbles form on the underside of some parts upon immersion, inhibiting contact with the cleaning liquid and preventing cleaning (or plating) from occuring.
  6. The air stream also introduces oxygen into the tank, which encourages oxidation.
  7. Air can cause detergents formulated for soak-tank degreasing to foam, which is always a negative since it is dragged into the initial rinse, contaminating that stage.

Tank agitation constantly presents fresh detergent to the surface of the parts. Bottom line: the solution is the solution. Agitation further enhances soil removal.

Submerged turbulence using eductors is a type of tank agitation and, for most applications, the most effective way to clean parts while minimizing process time and optimizing bath life. With this under-surface turbulence, the plume of liquid coming from the eductor passes over the surface of the part and generates a mechanical scrubbing action that enhances the cleaning effect.

The nozzle generates a high-velocity fluid jet to entrain the liquid surrounding the eductor. The fluid in the nozzle jet and the entrained liquid are forced through a diffuser, where the high-throughput velocity creates a turbulent flow. This turbulence mixes the two fluids while avoiding foaming and agitation at the air-liquid interface.

The advantage of an eductor is that the discharge plume is much broader than the jet from a solid-stream nozzle of equivalent energy. Notably, eductors enable small pumps to efficiently circulate large volumes of tank solution. Each eductor circulates a tank volume equal to four to five times the solution volume pumped.

Eductors also suspend solids, and sweep debris or sludge toward a filter intake. This simplifies filtration and greatly reduces particulate settling on the tank bottom—a major maintenance headache. Eductors also mix and agitate without introducing foreign matter, reducing solution temperature or creating liquid layers. Well-engineered eductors are also clog-resistant, have no moving parts and last an extremely long, maintenance-free amount of time. 

Agitating 50× per hour can result in reduction of cleaning time up to one-third. Parts with blind holes using directed eductor solution agitation can expect a reduction in cleaning time of as much as 50 percent.

Eductors are a cost-effective way to enhance the power of virtually any cleaning solution. Benefits of submerged turbulence include faster processing, extended bath life, less external contamination and lower oxidation corrosion potential.

There also are other options for agitating tanks that can improve the cleaning potential of a stagnant soak tank:

Ultrasonics—sound waves produced by a submerged transducer—create tiny bubbles that implode on the part surface. This implosion releases high energy, which creates heat and power to assist in the scrubbing action. The ultrasonic frequency determines the cleaning power: Lower frequencies are more powerful and less directed; higher frequencies are less powerful but can be directed to the part. This method is best for small tanks due to the high equipment cost.

Stroke is simple vertical movement of the parts within the tank solution. Parts are typically racked on a platform, which then moves through the tank. This action keeps fresh cleaning solution on the part surface and moves the solution to keep it well-circulated within the tank. 

Tumbling agitation is used for parts with cavities and blind holes that can entrap the solution. These parts are racked in a basket or fixture that rotates within the cleaning solution. Some applications, particularly those with very fast processing speeds, combine tumbling with eductors.

Recirculation involves pumping the solution from one end to the other, creating a constant, low-speed, fluid flow. More effective recirculation is possible with eductors.

Steve Phillips is the U.S. sales manager for Bex Inc. Visit bex.com

high-performance systems for efficient parts cleaning
Cleaning Technologies Group
Echoflex modular ultrasonic cleaning machines
vacuum vapor degreasers
Pickelx one step metal prep
Precision Cleaning Solvents
Cleaning questions ask Kyzen
Heatmax Heaters ad with immersion heaters
Heatmax Heaters ad with immersion heaters
The Finishing Industry’s Education and Networking Resource
find masking products online
Filtration Systems

Related Content

Parts Cleaning

3-Stage Versus 5-Stage Washers

Columnist Rodger Talbert explains the difference between a five-stage washer and a three-stage washer, and how one provides better corrosion protection over the other. 

Read More
Ask The Expert

Top Reasons to Switch to a Better Cleaning Fluid

Venesia Hurtubise from MicroCare says switching to the new modern cleaning fluids will have a positive impact on your cleaning process.

Read More

Corrosion Resistance Testing for Powder Coating

Salt spray can be useful to help compare different pretreatment methods and coatings but it does not tell us much about the corrosion resistance of a part over time in the field. Powder coating expert Rodger Talbert offers insights into how to get a better idea of how to improve a part’s corrosion resistance in the real world.

Read More
Parts Cleaning

Pretreatment of Black Oxide

Having issues achieving a consistent color with the application of black oxide? Start by looking at your pretreatment. Connor Callais of Hubbard-Hall offers advice for troubleshooting your black oxide process.

Read More

Read Next

sustainability

Episode 45: An Interview with Chandler Mancuso, MacDermid Envio Solutions

Chandler Mancuso, technical director with MacDermid Envio discusses updating your wastewater treatment system and implementing materials recycling solutions to increase efficiencies, control costs and reduce environmental impact.

Read More
Sponsored

Masking Solutions for Medical Applications

According to Custom Fabricating and Supplies, a cleanroom is ideal for converting, die cutting, laminating, slitting, packaging and assembly of medical-grade products.

Read More
workforce development

Education Bringing Cleaning to Machining

Debuting new speakers and cleaning technology content during this half-day workshop co-located with IMTS 2024.

Read More
Vacuum Degreasers and Aqueous Solutions