The Voice of the Finishing Industry since 1936

  • PF Youtube
  • PF Facebook
  • PF Twitter
  • PF LinkedIn
11/1/2015 | 1 MINUTE READ

Mass Finishing Q&A: Robotic or Dedicated Deburring Machine

Facebook Share Icon LinkedIn Share Icon Twitter Share Icon Share by EMail icon Print Icon

Which deburring machine do you recommend?

Q. We have a stainless part that needs deburring. Our deburring machine choice is a robot or a dedicated specialty automated deburring machine. Which would you recommend we purchase?

A. If production rates can be met by both systems and the pricing is relatively the same, I recommend the robot. We have sold the dedicated machines for years. Once the product is changed or discontinued, the dedicated machine becomes a boat anchor. If the burr is larger than average, the dedicated machine may not work and sending the part through the machine twice is not practical. However, dedicated machines produce large production rates and can be faster than robots.

On the other hand, an industrial robot is multipurpose, which is with declining product life cycles, improved quality requirements, deburring time cycle flexibility and reduced production rates.

Consider the average robot service life of 15 years. The dedicated machine may also last 15 years, but will the job last 15 years? Most U.S. manufacturers look for a one-year machine payback. If a robot is paid for in one year, there are 14 more years that it can be used for other projects. Flexibility is key. Manufacturing in the U.S. is moving toward specialty industries, more complex parts and less production.

Robots work well in these environments.

Originally published in the November 2015 issue.

Related Topics


  • Investigation of Tin Whisker Formation

    Immersion tin and lead-free hot air solder leveling (HASL) coatings based on SnCu or SnAgCu alloys are widely used as surface finish materials for printed circuit boards (PCB). These coatings prevent the underlying copper from corrosion and preserve its solderability during lead-free assembly processes and for a long storage life of PCBs.

  • Chemically Accelerated Vibratory Surface Finishing (CAVSF) with Oxalic Acid-Based Solutions

    It has been shown that the inexpensive chemically accelerated vibratory surface finishing (CAVSF) process can reduce the average surface roughness.

  • Microabrasive Precision Shot Peening

    Precision shot peening brings an entirely new concept to the field of microabrasive blasting, and it is complementary to its larger cousin. Using glass bead media, several companies have been shot peening for years with microabrasive blasting technology.