Zinc-Rich Powder as a Basecoat on Aluminum

Question:

We are working with the Air Force on integrating powder coatings in their support equipment painting process lines. Some initial panel testing is required by the government. Most of the panels are carbon steel, and the environmental folks are against any phosphate pretreatment (zinc or iron). There are several zinc-rich epoxy powders that we had tested a few years ago with good results when topcoated with a TGIC polyester or epoxy powder coating. So, we recommended that if they are hard set against the phosphating pretreatments to at least use the zinc-rich powder coatings as a basecoat with an appropriate topcoat. We have one faction that wants to apply the zinc-rich powder as a basecoat on aluminum 2024, 6065 and 7075 alloys. Our position is while the aluminum is fairly corrosion resistant you wouldn't want to set up the potential for galvanic (dissimilar metals) corrosion by putting the zinc in contact with the aluminum. Do you know of any advantage that may be derived from putting zinc powder as a basecoat on aluminum? What is your opinion on using the zinc-rich powder coating on aluminum? M.S.

Answer:

It seems that politics are everywhere these days. You have differing opinions in a government run program. This has all the makings of a real scandal or possibly an opportunity for a recount. Maybe we should call CNN!

Featured Content

TTX Environmental Solves Customer Issue with Electro-Ceramic Desalination Wastewater Processing

Fixing Corrosion Between Anodized Aluminum and Steel

Polishing vs. Buffing: What's the Difference?

Politics aside, there are several items in your question that are intriguing. First, the "environmental folks" don't want to use iron phosphates because some jurisdictions frown on their use. But, these same people will allow zinc-rich powder coating primers to be used freely. Iron phosphate (classified as non-hazardous waste) can be diluted or deflocculated easily before dumping the wastewater to drain, but the zinc-rich powder primer is classified hazardous waste and must be delivered to a special landfill with appropriate paperwork and cradle-to-grave liability. Sounds like another government solution (like "trickle down economics") that is based upon convoluted logic.

Secondly, the zinc-rich primer works on mild steel because of the same dissimilar metal reaction that has you concerned if you coat over aluminum. The position the dissimilar metals are on the galvanic scale determines which metal is "sacrificed" to the corrosion. In this case zinc is "sacrificed" over the steel, therefore, the steel is left corrosion free as long as the zinc is still present. My engineering handbooks are currently in storage, so I'm not sure where aluminum places on the galvanic scale in comparison to zinc. But, if you check it that will give you the answer you need. What you don't want is the aluminum to be "sacrificed" over the zinc. Personally, I don't think that the zinc-rich primer will significantly improve the corrosion resistance of the aluminum. Coating some test panels with the subject materials and running salt spray testing will give you the answer you need. This way we don't have to depend upon theory alone to guide us through this problem.